How to Know You Are Making High Quality Content

Stop Guessing If Your Content Is Good

Here’s a common problem: you write content for your website, then spend hours debating whether it’s “high quality” or not. These conversations usually end up being about personal opinions instead of facts.

Here’s the real issue: You can’t be objective about something you created. Your judgement is naturally biased, which makes it almost impossible to know if your content is actually good without real data.

Why Your Current Metrics Don’t Tell the Whole Story

Most website owners look at these signals to guess if their content is working:

• Bounce rate – People often think this means engagement, but users might leave because they already got their answer
• Time on page – More time could mean great content OR a confusing page
• Engagement rates – Your page design might be causing this, not your content
• Traffic numbers – Lots of visitors doesn’t mean they found what they needed

These numbers show you what happened, but not why it happened. They don’t tell you if people actually found your content helpful.

The Simple Solution: Just Ask

Instead of trying to guess from confusing metrics, do something simple and direct:

Method 1: Simple feedback buttons

"Was this article helpful?"
[👍 Yes] [👎 No]

Method 2: Comment section

Enable comments at the bottom of your article so users can share what they think, ask questions, or point out missing information.

Method 3: Simple feedback form Add a small form asking:

• Did this help? (Yes/No)
• What could be better? (Text box)
• Your email (optional)

Method 4: Pop-up survey When users are about to leave or after they’ve been on page for 30 seconds, show a quick pop-up: “Quick question: Did you find what you were looking for?”

Method 5: Embedded poll

Add a simple poll widget in your content: “How would you rate this guide?”

Method 6: Star rating widget

Let users rate your content with stars (1-5) with one click.

Method 7: Live chat widget

Add a chat box where users can immediately tell you if something’s unclear or missing.

Method 8: Reaction buttons (like social media)

Add emoji reactions users can click

Why This Works

1. Clear answers – People tell you directly if your content helped them
2. Easy to use – Takes just one click to respond
3. Works at scale – You can add this to every page on your site
4. Shows you problems – You’ll clearly see which pages aren’t working

How to Set It Up

• Put feedback buttons at the bottom of every article
• Link them to your analytics tool (like Google Analytics)
• Track both thumbs up and thumbs down responses
• Add an optional text box where people can explain more

Understanding the Results

One important thing to know: More people will give negative feedback than positive. That’s just human nature – we’re more motivated to complain than to praise.

But here’s the good news: this happens the same way on all your pages. So you can still compare them. A page with 20% negative feedback is doing better than one with 60% negative feedback.

What to Do With the Feedback

When you find pages getting lots of negative feedback, ask yourself:

1. Are You Meeting Expectations?

• Does your title promise something the article doesn’t deliver?
• Are people searching for one thing but finding something else?

2. Is Information Missing?

• Did you skip important details?
• Are there common questions you didn’t answer?
• Do competitor pages cover things you missed?

3. Is Your Content Hard to Use?

• Is information buried or hard to find?
• Are your explanations confusing?
• Does your page layout match what people are looking for?

4. Does Your Content Match the Search?

• Your content might be accurate but not what people actually wanted
• Check what search terms are bringing people to that page

Step-by-Step Setup Guide

Step 1: Add the Feedback Tool

Choose how to collect feedback:

• Write custom code
• Use a feedback widget tool
• Install a plugin if you use WordPress

Connect it to your analytics:

• Send feedback data to your analytics platform
• Set it up so you can easily see the results

Step 2: Collect Data First

• Wait at least 4-6 weeks before making changes
• This gives you enough data to see real patterns
• Calculate the average feedback score across your whole site

Step 3: Find Problem Pages

Focus on pages that are:

• Getting lots of traffic but bad feedback (fix these first – biggest impact)
• Important for your business but not satisfying users
• Ranking well in search but making users unhappy (you might lose these rankings)

Step 4: Dig Deeper

For pages that need work:

• Add a comment box asking “What was missing?” or “How can we improve?”
• Look for patterns in the comments
• Check what competing pages are doing better
• Consider testing your page with real users

Step 5: Fix and Track

• Make specific improvements to problem pages
• Watch how feedback changes after your updates
• Give it a few weeks to see results

What Else You Get From This Data

Beyond just improving content, this feedback helps you:

1. Know what to write next – Topics that get positive feedback might be good for more related articles
2. Justify your budget – Show bosses or clients real proof that content is working
3. Measure your team – Track how well your content creators are doing
4. Improve search rankings – Google values content that satisfies users, and this data helps you create exactly that

Understanding what makes content helpful is also important for ranking well in search engines.

Common Questions

“Won’t most people ignore it?” Yes, most will. But even if just 2-5% of visitors respond, that’s enough useful data when you apply it across your whole site.

“Can’t competitors give fake negative feedback?” Technically yes, but they’d need to do it at a huge scale across many pages to actually affect your data. Just watch for weird patterns.

“Isn’t this just a vanity metric?” No. Unlike social media likes, this directly tells you if your content did what it was supposed to do. That’s the real measure of quality.

Start Small and Simple

You don’t need fancy tools or a big budget. Just start with:

1. A simple yes/no button on your top 20 pages
2. Basic tracking in your existing analytics
3. Check the data once a month
4. Fix the worst-performing content first

The big shift: Stop defending whether content should be good. Start measuring whether it actually is good for real users.

If you need help with the technical side of improving content quality, our technical SEO services can help.

Final Thoughts

Arguing about content quality based on opinions doesn’t help anyone. When you add simple feedback tools, you get real data that shows exactly which content works and which doesn’t.

The best part: there’s basically no downside. Even if you don’t act on the data right away, you’re building a valuable collection of information about what your users actually want.

Stop guessing. Start measuring.

For more articles, visit our blog category.